A lower price is not always a better purchase: comparing quotations

Imagine receiving three quotations for a project: one quotes per board, another per square metre, and a third includes freight in the final amount. Picking the lowest number is not yet an economic comparison. First establish a common basis, then examine the payable cost alongside practical terms.

Step 1: Make sure you are discussing the same product

Thickness, dimensions, brand or model, facing type, colour code, quality grade and quantity must be identifiable in every quotation. Put a supplier’s proposed alternative on a separate line; do not hide technical differences under the same heading.

For a new request, enter the information once in a consistent format and send the same specifications to every supplier. If a specification changes after quotations arrive, make the revised request clear to everyone so that you do not compare two different versions.

Step 2: Align the pricing unit

Worked example: a board measuring 1220 × 2440 mm has an area of 2.9768 square metres. At a hypothetical price of OMR 10, its price per square metre is approximately OMR 3.36. These figures illustrate the calculation only and are not market prices.

The basic formula is simple: length in metres × width in metres = board area. Then divide the board price by its area. This conversion is useful only when thickness, material and quality are equivalent. Even after conversion, the cutting pattern and number of usable pieces can change the project outcome.

Step 3: Record the delivered cost

Use one column for the goods after discount and separate columns for tax, packaging, freight, agreed insurance and unloading. Specify which costs are included and which amounts still need confirmation. A total with unresolved costs should not be presented as final.

The quotation currency must also be clear. If you convert currencies, record the rate and reference time; a mental conversion or old rate is insufficient for the final decision. The site’s comparison table displays each product’s currency and unit beside the price so that different bases remain visible to the buyer.

Step 4: Read timing and terms alongside the price

• Price validity: until what date and for what purchase quantity is the quotation valid?
• Supply: is stock ready, or must it be sourced after ordering? From which event does the preparation lead time begin?
• Payment: what deposit, settlement stages and conditions for starting preparation apply?
• Delivery: are the destination, transport coordinator, unloading responsibility and required documents clearly specified?
• Discrepancies: how and within what agreed period should shortages or damage be reported?

Step 5: Check technical claims and certificates

If the project requires a particular certificate, ask for its name, number and scope in the quotation. For example, FSC provides a public certificate search tool that can be used to check certificate status and scope. A logo in a catalogue alone is not independent verification.

Attach all documents to the final quotation version. If a check remains inconclusive, ask the supplier for clarification before making a final choice; an unclear lowest-price quotation usually makes comparison harder.

Record a brief decision that can be reviewed later

Beside the selected quotation, write two or three clear reasons: specification compliance, delivered cost, lead time or payment terms. This note keeps the reasoning behind the previous purchase available when prices change or you reorder.

On the site, first narrow suitable products using feature filters and add them to the comparison table. For purchases with unconfirmed prices or freight, submit a quotation request to receive a detailed proposal you can assess. The article image is an editorial illustration, not an actual supplier document.

Sources and further reading

Official FSC public certificate search tool

Guide to choosing MDF or particleboard

Request a quotation